Science produces models that provide parsimonious descriptions of the world. In cognitive psychology, models regularly compete to explain a few phenomena. But models can survive experiment after experiment, both because of the difficulty of capturing participant’s nuanced behavior, and because models often make highly overlapping predictions. In these cases, a model succeeds through its relative parsimony.
In cognitive psychology, measures of information criteria, specifically Akaike’s and the Bayesian information criteria (Schwarz 1978; Akaike 1973), determine a winning model.